In this photo taken by a drone, cleanup continues in the area where the ruptured Keystone pipeline dumped oil into a creek in Washington County, Kan., Friday, Dec. 9, 2022. (DroneBase via AP)
The Keystone pipeline leaked in Kansas. What makes this spill so bad?
By Jaclyn Diaz/NPR
(Washington County, Kan.) — It’s been over a week since TC Energy announced its Keystone pipeline leaked into Mill Creek in Washington County, Kan. Nearly 600,000 gallons of oil spilled into the waterway as well as the land surrounding it.
Environmental advocates say this is just the beginning to a cleanup that will likely take years.
Operators were alerted to an issue with the pipeline on Dec. 7. As of Friday morning, TC Energy says, 4,125 barrels of oil from the creek have been recovered of the estimated 14,000 barrels (about 588,000 gallons) reportedly lost in the spill.
Aerial footage of the leak from Nebraska Public Media shows the leak has affected a nearby pasture and residents’ farmland.
Many initial details, like the cause for the spill, are still not clear. What is known is the type of oil that was being transported through the pipeline: tar sands oil, also called diluted bitumen.
This thick, toxic substance makes cleanup so much more difficult, said Jane Kleeb, the founder of Bold Alliance, and Anthony Swift, director of the Canada Project with the Natural Resources Defense Council, both environmental advocacy groups.
“When a tar sands disaster like this happens, it is worse than a traditional oil spill. Because tar sands is much more difficult, expensive and much more toxic to clean up. We know that this is going to take years,” Kleeb told NPR. She said she’s been monitoring oil spills, particularly tar sands spills, for 14 years.
She also notes that, in her experience, initial estimates of the amount of oil actually spilled can be wrong.
“Usually, when this happens, that initial number ends up doubling,” she said.
The full picture of the leak won’t be known until the recovery process is completed.
In response to Kleeb’s comments, TC Energy told NPR in a statement, “Our commitment to the community is that our response efforts will continue until we have fully remediated the site. We have the people, expertise, training and equipment to mount an effective response and clean-up, and that’s what we’re doing.”
Diluted bitumen is like “peanut butter”
TC Energy, formerly known as TransCanada, says its Keystone pipeline runs from Canada to Oklahoma. (This Keystone pipeline is not to be confused with the canceled Keystone XL pipeline project that was a major flashpoint in the U.S. for years.)
Even though TC Energy maintains that it has the right training and equipment to effectively respond to the Mill Creek spill, the effort will be a daunting one, Swift said.
Bitumen doesn’t flow through a pipeline efficiently, “so it is mixed with diluents to be readied for pipeline transportation as diluted bitumen, or ‘dilbit,’ “ the American Petroleum Institute says.
“It’s a very thick substance that’s almost peanut butter consistency,” said Swift, with NRDC.
Most containment efforts don’t really work for bitumen, he says. In situations of other oil spills affecting waterways, one of the first steps is to set up booms to prevent the oil from spreading farther in the water.
Diluted bitumen “doesn’t float the way conventional oil does. And most means of spill remediation in water bodies do rely on most of the oil staying on top of the water body,” Swift said.
Bitumen eventually sinks to the bottom of rivers and wetlands, making containment, and the environmental consequences, far more difficult and expensive.
On land, this material causes major problems thanks to the bitumen’s incredibly strong adhesive properties, Swift said.
“Once this thick tar sands is on something, you basically have to just extract everything that this stuff has touched,” he said. “The bitumen can migrate and it tends to seep into soils. The longer it’s left, the more of a problem it can become.”
Experts compare this spill to a 2010 Kalamazoo incident
Both Kleeb and Swift said this latest Keystone leak reminds them of the 2010 Kalamazoo River oil spill.
In July 2010, over a million gallons of tar-sands crude oil was released into Talmadge Creek, a small tributary to the Kalamazoo River near Marshall, Mich., according to the Kalamazoo River Watershed Council. This environmental disaster was the result of a ruptured pipe from Enbridge Energy Partners LLC. The spill resulted in a 30-mile stretch of the Kalamazoo River getting contaminated.
“From 2010 to 2014, over 1.2 million gallons of oil were recovered from the river,” according to the Environmental Protection Agency. Estimates in the years since the cleanup suggest it cost over $1 billion.
Kansas and people on the ground are going to have to prepare for the long haul, Kleeb said.
“I haven’t seen a tar sands spill of this scope in a creek. We don’t know what that is going to look like and how it is impacting the biodiversity in that creek. And not to mention the pasture land,” Kleeb said.
“In the past, when we’ve seen the spills happen it impacts the land for years. They not only have to excavate all of the polluted soil, there is a lot of work to be done to make sure that this isn’t impacting the root system,” she said. “And now all of that precious topsoil, which is critical to agriculture, is now destroyed and will be destroyed forever.”
This is not TC Energy’s first, second, or third spill
Keystone has been the subject of 22 reported leaks since 2010, according a Government Accountability Office report last year. With the Mill Creek case, it is now up to at least 23.
“Keystone’s accident history has been similar to other crude oil pipelines since 2010, but the severity of spills has worsened in recent years,” GAO said. “Similar to crude oil pipelines nationwide, most of Keystone’s 22 accidents from 2010 through 2020 released fewer than 50 barrels of oil and were contained on operator-controlled property such as a pump station.”
Prior to construction, TC Energy got a special permit from the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA) to operate certain portions of the pipeline at a higher pressure level than is ordinarily allowed under agency regulations for oil transport.
Though the reason for the spill is still unknown, both Swift and Kleeb voiced concerns over this permit and questioned if the higher stress level was potentially a major factor in the latest spill.
“That is unusual, that is not the norm,” she said of the number of spills from this one pipeline. “They should have never given a company with this many spills a special permit to pump at higher pressure.”
PHMSA told NPR “regulations have extensive requirements for pipeline accident reporting.” Federal regulations require accident reports of incidents that have “a release of 5 gallons or more of hazardous liquid or carbon dioxide, with an exception for maintenance related releases,” an agency spokesman said.
Not including the Mill Creek leak, the two largest spills in Keystone’s history occurred in 2017 and 2019. As of Dec. 7, government data shows that this spill is the biggest in the pipeline’s history, the Associated Press reported.
In response to the Mill Creek case (as it has with each of Keystone’s largest previous spills), PHMSA issued “Corrective Action Orders,” the agency’s most stringent enforcement tool, a spokesman told NPR.