After months of litigation, a Philadelphia judge has ruled that a controversial immigrant youth center can open in Philadelphia’s Logan neighborhood.

The seven-member family, which includes two young children and a three-month-old infant, grabbed headlines when two members of the family alleged that their border crossing was accidental, and that they worried their baby would fall sick while in federal custody.

Some victims have used the program to put their fight with the church behind them. Others scoffed at the price tag put on their trauma. This is the story of two men who came to different conclusions.