Skip Navigation

Harrisburg water authority sues state to force wastewater payments, $2.4 million owed so far

Lawsuit has statewide implications for local wastewater management funding. Capitol Region Water says costs could go up 50% if state doesn’t pay.

  • Jordan Wilkie/WITF
Marc Kurowski, a civil engineer who leads Capital Region Water’s board, speaks at a news conference announcing a lawsuit against the state over paying stormwater fees on Oct. 13, 2026.

 Jordan Wilkie / WITF News

Marc Kurowski, a civil engineer who leads Capital Region Water’s board, speaks at a news conference announcing a lawsuit against the state over paying stormwater fees on Oct. 13, 2026.

When it rains too hard or too much snow melts, Harrisburg’s combined sewage and stormwater systems pump human waste into the Susquehanna River and Paxton Creek.

That prevents overwhelming the wastewater treatment plant, but it also violates state and federal clean water laws, per a 2015 legal agreement agreed to by the City of Harrisburg, Capital Region Water authority, and the federal Environmental Protection Agency.

To fix the problem, Capital Region Water is on a 40-year, $1.4 billion plan to upgrade the storm- and wastewater pipes running under Harrisburg, three-quarters of which are over 100 years old.

That money needs to come from somewhere, and Capital Region Water is suing the Commonwealth to force the state to pay for stormwater services. Pennsylvania’s state-owned properties take up a higher proportion of land in the Harrisburg area than in any other local water authority, according to Charlotte Katzenmoyer, Capital Region Water’s executive director.

If the state doesn’t pay for stormwater runoff from state properties, then local homeowners and business will have to.

“That’s not affordable for many Harrisburg families,” she said. “More than a third of those households live at or below the federal poverty level.”

Passing the costs on would not be fair, Katzenmoyer said. Capital Region Water used to issue bills for combined stormwater and wastewater management, but that system also put a heavier burden on smaller property owners. In 2020, the water authority introduced a separate stormwater billing scheme based on the size of a property and how much is covered with surfaces that are not absorptive, like pavement or rooftops, and direct water into gutters.

The state has never paid that bill.

After six years of negotiation, Capital Region Water is suing because of confusion introduced by a recent state Supreme Court ruling, Borough of West Chester v. PASSHE.

In that case, a divided set of justices decided stormwater billing is taxation, not a fee. That means tax-exempt entities like the state and nonprofits can’t be forced to foot the bill.

But Capital Region Water’s case has a different set of facts from West Chester’s, according to Katzenmoyer and her team, and they believe state law is on their side.

The disagreement and the litigation are not political, according to Marc Kurowski, a civil engineer who leads Capital Region Water’s board. They need to solve a legal disagreement between two public authorities, so they are taking it to the courts.

Paul Vezzetti, spokesperson for the Department of General Services, said Capital City Water provides critical services, and he pointed to the West Chester ruling showing stormwater charges are a local tax from which the state is exempted.

“We will continue to be a responsible partner in the communities where Commonwealth facilities are located and address the issues raised in this lawsuit through the appropriate legal process,” Vezzetti said.

The case has implications for water authorities across the state.

If none of Harrisburg’s tax-exempt entities pay for stormwater management, bills could go up by more than 50% for homeowners and local businesses, according to Capital Region Water.

“Someone still has to pay for the infrastructure, the maintenance, the operations, and all of the regulatory compliance necessary to manage that water,” Kurowski said.

There’s another way this issue could have been solved. The state legislature could update laws to clarify who must pay what. Though some bills have been introduced, none have passed.

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Up Next
Politics & Policy

Pa. nonprofits, businesses look to replace revenue from skill games