This Juniata County museum holds the history of a once-bustling 19th-century academy
-
Asia Tabb
aired; September 28, 2026
If you drove through the small community surrounding the Tuscarora Academy Museum in Juniata County today, you might not guess that the area was once home to a bustling 19th-century boarding school.
The building that now houses the museum was originally built as a church in 1816. When the Tuscarora Academy opened in 1836, the church sanctuary became part of the school. The academy eventually grew into a respected college-preparatory boarding school that attracted students from at least 30 states.
At its peak, about 80 students attended each semester. Students studied subjects including Latin, Greek and classical education, while also taking part in activities that sound surprisingly familiar today.
“They would go sledding. They would go skating. There was a nearby stream where they would swim in the summertime. There was, they played baseball,” said Jessica Eaton Guyer, curator of the Tuscarora Academy Museum and president of the Juniata County Historical Society. “It was just like any other school that you would think of now, just in the 19th century.”
The academy eventually became coeducational after a nearby girls’ school closed in 1873. Free public high schools and school consolidation eventually made it harder for the academy to attract students, and the institution closed after roughly 80 years.
Today, the museum preserves pieces of that history, along with artifacts from throughout Juniata County. Some are traditional historical documents and photographs. Others are much more unusual.
The museum has a framed piece of human skin bearing a tattoo, donated from the collection of a family of doctors who practiced in the county for generations.
“It’s the weird history that brings people out. Really, it does,” Guyer said.
The Juniata County Historical Society also maintains other historic properties, cemeteries, documents and photographs. Guyer said one of the biggest challenges is finding enough funding and volunteers to care for those resources.
The Tuscarora Academy Museum is now the last remaining building from what was once an almost nine-acre academy campus, giving visitors a chance to step inside both the building and the history of the community that once surrounded it.
Listen to the podcast to hear the full conversation.