Skip Navigation

‘Self-Identities’ podcast talks to women serving life in jail for murder

Host Dr. Dr. Kathryn Whiteley and producer AJ Nutter combine for a unique podcast

  • By Marquis Lupton

Aired; March 29th, 2024.

AJ Nutter and Dr. Kate Whiteley are the host and producer of the thought-provoking podcast “Self-Identities,” which takes a unique approach to storytelling by engaging in conversations with convicted women murderers serving life sentences. Dr. Kathryn Whiteley, a feminist criminologist, leads the podcast as the primary host, with AJ Nutter serving as co-producer. “Self-Identities” stands apart from typical true crime narratives by eschewing the sensationalism often associated with the genre. Instead of focusing on the crimes committed by the women, the podcast delves into their personal stories and identities. By doing so, it aims to offer listeners an educational experience that goes beyond surface-level narratives.

The podcast’s premise is to humanize these women, providing a platform for them to share their experiences and perspectives. Through candid conversations, listeners gain insight into the complexities of these individuals’ lives, moving beyond the labels of “convict” or “murderer” to explore the nuances of their identities. Dr. Kathryn Whiteley’s expertise as a feminist criminologist lends depth and sensitivity to the discussions, fostering an environment where the women feel heard and understood. Meanwhile, AJ Nutter’s role as co-producer ensures the smooth operation of the podcast, from conceptualization to execution.

“Self-Identities” challenges societal perceptions of convicted criminals, offering a fresh perspective on empathy and understanding. By amplifying the voices of these women, the podcast encourages listeners to confront their preconceived notions and engage in meaningful dialogue about the complexities of crime and punishment. Through its commitment to education and engagement, “Self-Identities” serves as a beacon of empathy in a genre often marked by voyeurism and exploitation. By centering the stories of these women, the podcast not only sheds light on their individual experiences but also prompts broader discussions about justice, rehabilitation, and societal responsibility.

As “Self-Identities” continues to captivate audiences with its compelling narratives, it reinforces the power of storytelling as a tool for empathy and social change. In a world where true crime entertainment often prioritizes sensationalism over substance, this podcast offers a refreshing and enlightening alternative, inviting listeners to see beyond the headlines and embrace the humanity of those society has deemed irredeemable.

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Up Next
The Spark

The Harrisburg Singers excited to celebrate 40 years