Shapiro remains lone Dem among crowded field for 2022 Pa. governor’s race

  • Katie Meyer/WHYY

With Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf nearing his term limit, the 2022 contest for Pennsylvania governor is wide open.

This is a race that will have enormous implications for Pennsylvanians. Over the nearly eight years Wolf has been in office, members of the GOP-controlled legislature have become increasingly conservative — something that appears unlikely to change in the near term. Wolf’s veto pen has often been the only thing standing in the way of GOP efforts to, for instance, narrow abortion rightsimpose voter ID, and bar certain vaccine requirements.

Cook Political Report analyst Jessica Taylor, who is tracking gubernatorial races around the country, has the race rated as one of the country’s few true toss-ups. She notes, though, that will very likely change depending on who Republicans pick in their May 2022 primary.

That side of the race is especially competitive, with as many as seven — and possibly more — candidates duking it out to capture voters’ attention. Most of them also want attention from former President Donald Trump, whose influence holds tremendous sway among many of the commonwealth’s Republicans.

“This field is one I have a hard time getting a handle on, frankly,” Taylor said. “And talking with people, I kind of get that same sense. It’s still not really clear.”

What is much clearer, she noted, is the Democratic side. There’s only one major candidate on that side of the aisle — something that bodes well for the party’s overall chances.

“I think at this point, probably Democrats are feeling pretty good about it right now,” Taylor said.

Democrats likely to join the race

Josh Shapiro, 48

Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro speaks during a news conference in Philadelphia, Tuesday, May 14, 2019.

Matt Rourke / AP Photo

Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro speaks during a news conference in Philadelphia, Tuesday, May 14, 2019.

Current occupation: Pennsylvania Attorney General
Political history: Montgomery County Commissioner, State Representative
Hometown: Abington

Shapiro isn’t officially in the race for governor yet, but he’s been laying the groundwork for his bid for much of 2021 — and, many in Pennsylvania would argue, since the very beginning of his political career. Announcement notwithstanding, he is considered the frontrunner for the Democratic nomination, and potentially the only major candidate.

The Montgomery County Democrat began his political career in the State House, then served as a Montco commissioner before becoming Attorney General in 2017, ending a period of instability in the office. Perhaps his most significant action as AG was presiding over the release of a landmark grand jury report on decades of sexual abuse of children in Catholic dioceses across Pennsylvania. He subsequently supported retroactive lawsuits in cases where people abused as children were barred from suing because too much time had passed.

Throughout the administration of former President Donald Trump, he held himself as a firm opponent and added his name to dozens of joint lawsuits with other Democratic attorneys general on issues including Trump’s border wall, his administration’s policies on contraception, and his election-time changes to post office operations. During the 2020 election, he was a frequent cable news commentator and Trump critic as well.

But Shapiro, generally considered a political pragmatist, has also clashed with those to his left. Progressive Philly DA Larry Krasner is a semi-frequent opponent; the two tangled over a bill that gave Shapiro more control over prosecuting Philly gun crimes (though Shapiro tried to smooth the conflict over) and Krasner later sued the AG for settling with opioid distributors and manufacturers.

Republican candidates

Lou Barletta, 65

FILE PHOTO: U.S. Rep. Lou Barletta meets with reporters following his second debate with U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-PA, Friday Oct. 26, 2018, in the studio of KDKA-TV in Pittsburgh.

Gene J. Puskar / AP Photo

FILE PHOTO: U.S. Rep. Lou Barletta meets with reporters following his second debate with U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-PA, Friday Oct. 26, 2018, in the studio of KDKA-TV in Pittsburgh.

Current occupation: Retired
Political history: U.S. Congressman (PA-11), candidate for U.S. Senate in 2018, mayor of Hazleton
Hometown: Hazelton

Barletta, a former four-term congressman who ran for U.S. Senate in 2018 and lost badly to incumbent Democrat Bob Casey, is one of the many Republicans in Pennsylvania’s 2022 races hoping to use Trump’s 2016 success in the state to his advantage.

Barletta decided to mount another statewide office run after being out of the political spotlight for two years, he says, because he was frustrated with Wolf’s pandemic mitigation measures. In the early days of COVID-19, they included broad business shutdowns.

He also says he wants to make sure coal, oil, and natural gas production doesn’t slow in Pennsylvania. He opposes the commonwealth’s expansion of mail-in ballot use, plans to protect police budgets from potential cuts, and would fight against “sanctuary cities” like Philadelphia, where local officials pledge not to cooperate with federal immigration officials to deport undocumented people.

Barletta was one of the first congressional members to endorse Trump, and Trump endorsed him in his ill-fated 2018 Senate run. Barletta remains a staunch supporter of the former president, supporting baseless calls for 2020 election audits, and convening what he calls an Election Integrity Advisory Board to come up with ways to repeal and replace the voting law that expanded Pennsylvania’s use of mail ballots.

Barletta began his career as mayor of Hazleton, a former coal boom town that in the wake of deindustrialization saw a sharp rise in its Latino population. During his tenure, Barletta attracted national attention for trying to pass an ordinance that would have punished landlords and businesses for renting to or employing undocumented immigrants. Court challenges kept it from being enforced, and it ended up costing Hazelton $1.4 million in legal fees.

William McSwain, 52

Kimberly Paytner / WHYY

U.S. Attorney William McSwain outside the federal courthouse in Philadelphia.

Current occupation: Private practice attorney
Political history: U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania
Hometown: West Chester

McSwain, the recently-departed U.S. Attorney for Pennsylvania’s eastern district, is running on a tough-on-crime platform and raising some of the most heavily-discussed issues in conservative circles aligned with Trump, including: pandemic-related mandates, teaching about systemic racism in schools, and election security.

His tenure as U.S. attorney was marked by vocal opposition to self-identified “sanctuary cities,” like Philadelphia. He clashed repeatedly with Philly Mayor Jim Kenney and District Attorney Larry Krasner, opposing a city plan for a supervised opioid injection site and blaming their policies for rising homicide and gun crime rates.

McSwain stepped down as U.S. Attorney soon after Trump left the White House, and has since stressed the fact that he was appointed by the former president.

He has also attempted to curry the president’s favor when it comes to election fraud claims — while carefully avoiding saying he thinks any actual fraud took place. Before the 2020 election, McSwain issued a pointed statement saying he intended to watch carefully for potential election issues — though he ultimately didn’t file any fraud cases. Ahead of his formal campaign announcement, McSwain sent a widely-discussed letter to Trump — which Trump promptly publicized — asking for his support and claiming that former Trump Attorney General Bill Barr had prevented him from publicizing his concerns about election “irregularities.” Barr strongly disputed McSwain’s re-telling, calling his letter “deceptive” and saying McSwain was simply trying to keep Trump from publicly insulting him.

McSwain, who lives in West Chester, is a Harvard Law graduate and former Marine infantry officer. Before his appointment as U.S. attorney, he worked as a federal prosecutor and was a partner in the Philadelphia law firm Drinker, Biddle & Reath, mainly focusing on white-collar criminal defense. After his departure from the U.S. attorney’s office, he started with the Philadelphia law firm Duane Morris LLP.

Charlie Gerow, 66

CharlieforGovPA / Twitter

Charlie Gerow campaigning in Hershey, Pa.

Current occupation: GOP strategy and communications; CPAC vice-chair
Political history: Worked on Ronald Reagan’s presidential campaign, repeat RNC delegate, congressional candidate in 1998 and 2000, longtime political analyst
Hometown: Harrisburg

Gerow, a central Pennsylvania-based Republican strategist, and frequent conservative commentator has so far run a campaign that stresses his establishment conservative bona fides, while also echoing popular rhetoric from the Trumpist wing of the party.

In the video announcing his campaign, he accused established politicians and “the liberal media” of trying “to cancel” people who critique them, and said he wanted to fight against “liberals, socialists or anarchists out to destroy what our founding fathers sacrificed for, and our soldiers bled for.”

Gerow has pledged to support the natural gas industry and oppose pandemic mask mandates. He told the Pennsylvania Capital-Star that he thinks the commonwealth should be more cautious about using no-excuse absentee ballots, but also told the Philadelphia Inquirer that he acknowledged Joe Biden as the legitimate winner of the 2020 election.

He noted in his introductory campaign video that he started his career as a staffer for Ronald Reagan’s first presidential campaign. He has since been a fixture in Harrisburg, founding the public affairs company Quantum Communications in 2001 after unsuccessful bids for state senate and congress in the ‘80s and ‘90s.

Joe Gale, 31

Zoom

Montgomery County Commissioner Joe Gale.

Current occupation: Montgomery County Commissioner
Political history: Worked as a clerk in the county Recorder of Deeds department
Hometown: Plymouth Township

Gale, a Montgomery County commissioner since 2015, has sought to brand himself as the most Trump-aligned candidate in the field.

On his campaign website, Gale calls himself “pro-life, pro-2nd Amendment, pro-small business, pro-shale, pro-pipeline, pro-Trump and, most importantly, not controlled, influenced or endorsed by Republican Party bosses.” He also claims Trump’s presidency was “sabotaged” and told WHYY that virtually no Republican currently in elected office in Pennsylvania is conservative enough.

Gale was elected to his commissionership at 26 and has since tangled repeatedly with both his Democratic fellow commissioners, as well as his county’s Republican party.

The other commissioners called for his resignation after he said Black Lives Matter protesters were “hate groups” committing “urban domestic terror” during 2020’s widespread protests. After the Jan. 6 insurrection, he claimed there was a double standard for violent acts committed by the left and right wings. Commission Chair Valerie Arkoosh, who is running for U.S. Senate as a Democrat, has publicly called him a “racist.”

Republicans likely to join the race

Doug Mastriano, 57

Pennsylvania state Sen. Doug Mastriano, R-Franklin, attends a hearing of the Pennsylvania State Senate Majority Policy Committee, Wednesday, Nov. 25, 2020, in Gettysburg, Pa. Mastriano revealed five days later that he has COVID-19.

Julio Cortez / AP Photo

FILE PHOTO: Pennsylvania state Sen. Doug Mastriano, R-Franklin, attends a hearing of the Pennsylvania State Senate Majority Policy Committee, Wednesday, Nov. 25, 2020, in Gettysburg, Pa.

Current occupation: State Senator
Political history: 2018 congressional candidate (PA-13)
Hometown: Fayetteville

Mastriano, a state senator from Franklin County, has become a darling of the Trump-aligned wing of the Republican Party over the last several years, even as he has alienated himself from powerful GOP colleagues in the senate.

Mastriano spent thousands of dollars from his campaign account to rent buses to transport people to the Jan. 6 rallies in Washington D.C. that turned into an insurrection. He attended too, and later appeared to downplay how close he was to the violence.

Since Trump’s departure from office, Mastriano has been one of the loudest voices in Pennsylvania politics calling the 2020 presidential election into question. While it has become relatively mainstream among Pennsylvania Republicans to question the administration of the election and call for an “audit” on those grounds, Mastriano is part of a smaller, more extreme contingent that has insisted, falsely, that the 2020 election was rife with fraud.

Until recently, he led a Senate GOP initiative to conduct some form of election review. Senate President Pro Tempore Jake Corman (R-Centre) stripped him of that duty, and of his Harrisburg staff and committee chairmanship, after Mastriano unilaterally sent letters to three counties threatening subpoenas if they didn’t hand over election materials. Corman also accused Mastriano of being “​​interested in politics and showmanship and not actually getting things done.”

Mastriano is a retired U.S. Army colonel who served 30 years of active duty. He was elected to the Senate in 2019. During his time in elected office, he has also been a vocal opponent of abortion, mask mandates, and COVID-19 lockdowns.

He generally doesn’t return requests for comment, and hasn’t said when, or whether, he plans to formally announce his candidacy.

Dan Laughlin, 59

State Sen. Dan Laughlin, R-Erie County, is seen in his Senate office on June 11, 2019.

Ed Mahon / PA Post

FILE PHOTO: State Sen. Dan Laughlin, R-Erie County, is seen in his Senate office on June 11, 2019.

Current occupation: State Senator
Political history: Senate was first political office
Hometown: Erie

Laughlin, a state senator from Erie County who also owns a building company, would be the most moderate candidate in the Republican gubernatorial field — and he says he’s enjoying being in his own lane.

The district Laughlin has represented since 2017 takes up much of its county, including its biggest city, and is one of the purplest parts of Pennsylvania. Erie County went for Barack Obama in 2012, swung to Trump in 2016, then swung back to Biden in 2020.

Although he hasn’t officially announced that he’s turning his exploratory committee into a formal bid for governor, Laughlin has already begun acting as a cautious counterpoint to his likely opponents’ more conservative statements.

When a wave of Afghan refugees recently began arriving in the U.S., Lou Barletta told the Inquirer he couldn’t see how it was possible to “filter out jihadists bent on America’s destruction,” but Laughlin said while he also wanted a solid vetting process, “if you have an ounce of humanity you should realize we should help these folks who did make it to America.”

Laughlin was also one of Pennsylvania’s few elected Republicans to publicly criticize attempts to “audit” the 2020 election, writing in an op-ed that “Donald Trump lost Pennsylvania because Donald Trump received fewer votes,” and accusing his colleagues of wasting time.

Scott Martin, 51

Scott Martin

Sen. Scott Martin

Current occupation: State Senator
Political history: Lancaster County Commissioner, Director of Lancaster County’s Youth Intervention Center
Hometown: Lancaster

Martin, a state Senator since 2016, launched an exploratory committee for a gubernatorial run early this summer. He said he’s assessing support before committing to a run, and centered a desire to limit government, bolster free markets, and support small businesses in his initial press release announcing his interest.

Martin, who was a Lancaster County commissioner before his election to the Senate, heads the chamber’s education committee. He helped lead a recent amendment to the state constitution to limit Gov. Tom Wolf’s emergency powers, which voters approved.

Currently, he’s involved in initiatives to roll back the state health department’s powers to issue mask mandates and other directives. He supports limiting abortion rights, and has repeatedly sponsored a bill that would ban abortions performed because of a Down syndrome diagnosis.

​​

Pa. Republican lawmakers and the U.S. Capitol attack
As part of WITF’s commitment to standing with facts, and because the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol was an attempt to overthrow representative democracy in America, we are marking elected officials’ connections to the insurrection. Read more about this commitment.
State Sen. Doug Mastriano supported Donald Trump’s election-fraud lies by staging a policy committee meeting in November that gave Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani a platform for disinformation. Sens. Mastriano and Scott Martin were among the lawmakers who signed a letter urging members of Congress to delay certifying Pennsylvania’s electoral votes going to Joe Biden — despite no evidence that would call those results into question.

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Up Next
Politics & Policy

Pa. state Democratic lawmaker quietly stripped of committee leadership, Capitol access