Skip Navigation

Warrant: Peter Manfredonia accused in killings ‘just flipped’

The UConn senior was arrested in Hagerstown, Maryland, on May 27, ending a six-day police search in Pennsylvania and several other states.

  • By Dave Collins/The Associated Press
Pennsylvania State Police released this surveillance camera photograph taken May 27 at a Sheetz in Chambersburg, Pa., and said the man in the photograph could be murder suspect Peter Manfredonia.

 Submitted

Pennsylvania State Police released this surveillance camera photograph taken May 27 at a Sheetz in Chambersburg, Pa., and said the man in the photograph could be murder suspect Peter Manfredonia.

(Hartford, Conn.) — A University of Connecticut student charged with killing two people and seriously injuring a third told a witness “he just flipped” when he fatally slashed the first victim with a sword and he was remorseful, according to an arrest warrant affidavit released Monday.

Connecticut State Police released the warrant charging Peter Manfredonia, 23, from Newtown, with murder, attempted murder and assaulting an elderly person in connection with the violent attacks in Willington on May 22. He also is expected to be charged with murder in the killing of another man in Derby on May 24.

Manfredonia, a UConn senior who was studying finance and mechanical engineering, was arrested in Hagerstown, Maryland, on May 27, ending a six-day police search in several states, including Pennsylvania.

This photo provided by the Washington County, Maryland, Sheriff's Office, Thursday May 28, 2020, shows Peter Manfredonia. The college student wanted in connection with two killings and a kidnapping in Connecticut was taken into custody in Maryland after authorities tracked him to a truck stop, according to new details released by police on Thursday.

Washington County, Maryland, Sheriff's Office / The Associated Press

This photo provided by the Washington County, Maryland, Sheriff’s Office, Thursday May 28, 2020, shows Peter Manfredonia. The college student wanted in connection with two killings and a kidnapping in Connecticut was taken into custody in Maryland after authorities tracked him to a truck stop, according to new details released by police on Thursday.

The witness told police that Manfredonia broke into his Willington home after the first attack, held a gun to his head, tied him up and held him hostage for about 24 hours. He said they had several conversations before Manfredonia took his firearms and drove off in his truck.

“I asked if he wants to talk about what took place with the murder and he told me that he hadn’t slept for 5 days and that he just flipped,” the man told police, according to the warrant. “He said he didn’t know why he did it and that he was remorseful for it. … He was very careful about what he would say and it seemed like he didn’t want to face the reality of what happened.”

The man said he suggested Manfredonia turn himself in, but Manfredonia told him that wasn’t an option.

“He told me he was going to have two good weeks and then he figured it would end in either a shootout, the death penalty, or life in prison,” the man told police. Manfredonia surrendered peacefully to police when they spotted him and drew their guns, officials said.

Authorities allege Manfredonia killed 62-year-old Ted DeMers and seriously wounded another man in what appeared to be a samurai sword attack. The attack came while DeMers was giving Manfredonia a ride on the back of an ATV to Manfredonia’s motorcycle, which Manfredonia said he crashed down the road, the warrant said. The wounded man survived.

It’s not clear why Manfredonia was in DeMers’ neighborhood. But a female acquaintance of Manfredonia’s who lives near DeMers’ home told police she stopped seeing him after learning on March 18 that he had hacked into her social media accounts, police said. She had considered getting a restraining order against Manfredonia, police said.

This undated photo provided by the Connecticut State Police shows Peter Manfredonia. A woman who said she was abducted by Manfredonia, a college student suspected of killing two people in Connecticut, has been found safe in New Jersey, police said Monday, May 25, 2020. Manfredonia was last seen Sunday walking along railroad tracks in East Stroudsburg, Pa.

Courtesty of Connecticut State Police / AP Photo

This undated photo provided by the Connecticut State Police shows Peter Manfredonia. A woman who said she was abducted by Manfredonia, a college student suspected of killing two people in Connecticut, has been found safe in New Jersey, police said Monday, May 25, 2020.

State police also said Manfredonia had been “associated with numerous law enforcement investigations to include suicidal and homicidal ideation.”

Manfredonia’s lawyer, Michael Dolan, declined to comment on the allegations in the warrant but said, “We plan to mount a vigorous defense.” Dolan has said that Manfredonia had a history of depression and anxiety, but had never shown signs of violence.

After the home invasion, police said Manfredonia drove about 70 miles (110 kilometers) southwest to Derby and fatally shot a high school acquaintance, 23-year-old Nicholas Eisele. Manfredonia, then forced Eisele’s girlfriend into a car and fled the state.

The woman was found unharmed with the car at a rest stop near near Columbia, New Jersey, near the Pennsylvania line.

Investigators tracked Manfredonia to Pennsylvania, where police said he took an Uber to a Walmart in East Stroudsburg. Authorities searched the area but didn’t find him. A man fitting his description was later spotted near Scranton, Pennsylvania, prompting another search there.

Police believe Manfredonia stole a car and abandoned it in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, before taking another Uber to Hagerstown, where he was captured.

Manfredonia is being held on $7 million bail. He is scheduled to appear in court again on July 30 in connection with the Willington crimes.

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Up Next
Regional & State News

Berks County woman seeks taxpayer aid for defense in slaying of 2 kids