Lawsuit: ICE family detention in Pa. is a ‘tinderbox’ due to COVID-19

  • Laura Benshoff/WHYY

With our coronavirus coverage, our goal is to equip you with the information you need. Rather than chase every update, we’ll try to keep things in context and focus on helping you make decisions. See all of our stories here.

What you should know
» Coronavirus facts & FAQ
» Day-by-day look at coronavirus disease cases in Pa.
» It’s time to get serious about social distancing. Here’s how.

A lawsuit has been filed in federal court on behalf of 56 immigrant families held in detention centers in Pennsylvania and Texas, alleging they are “recklessly exposing” children and their parents to the coronavirus.

The suit urges a federal judge to compel their release. Advocates say the families — held for either civil charges or awaiting asylum decisions — could be monitored remotely, as is already the case for many immigrants.

“Respondents have failed to protect one of the most vulnerable populations in their charge: noncitizen asylum-seeking families in family detention,” write lawyers with ALDEA (People’s Justice Center) and the Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services. There are thousands of people in these centers in Karnes and Dilley, Texas, and 16 families in the Berks Family Residential Center, outside Reading, Pa., according to advocates.

The reality of living in close, confined quarters, often with multiple families sharing rooms and an alleged lack of additional cleaning or sanitary precautions create “a tinderbox that, once sparked, will create a crisis that threatens the lives of women, men and children,” write the attorneys.

The lawsuit follows another one filed in Washington State, where the ACLU has requested the release of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detainees, and a hunger strike in Newark, New Jersey. ICE has released some guidance about the steps it has taken to reduce the risk of transmitting COVID-19 to people in its custody, but has not yet provided a response to a request for comment.

Even under normal circumstances, it’s not uncommon for families transferred into ICE detention to be sick, often due to conditions on the trek to the United States or while waiting in Mexico to enter.

“Most of the people there have coughs,” said Jackie Kline, an attorney with ALDEA, who called it “surreal” that immigration detention continues, as do hearings for detained clients, as other courts are shutting down.

“The deportation machine has not stopped … and so it then forces all of these other segments, lawyers, judges, whatever to be put at risk,” she said.

The lawsuit alleges that current conditions violate the Fifth Amendment, the Administrative Procedures Act, and a legal settlement called Flores that protects the health and safety of minors in immigration custody. It requests the immediate release of families and the prevention of new families from entering.

It also points to a new precedent for reevaluating who really needs to be detained, citing a report that the Berks County Jail has already released 50-60 non-violent offenders who had already served a minimum sentence as a preventative measure.


Keystone Crossroads is a statewide reporting collaborative of WITF, WPSU and WESA, led by WHYY. This story originally appeared at https://whyy.org/programs/keystone-crossroads.

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Up Next
Regional & State News

Your afternoon update on the coronavirus in Pa.: Wolf issues stay-at-home order for hardest-hit counties