State House Sound Bites

Capitol reporter Mary Wilson covers Pennsylvania politics and issues at the Pennsylvania state capitol.

Bill would change endangered species determination process

Written by Mary Wilson, Capitol Bureau Chief | Jul 21, 2013 11:16 PM

Photo by Pennsylvania Game Commission

In Pennsylvania, the peregrine falcon is endangered and protected under the Game and Wildlife Code.

Two state agencies are warning proposed legislation would strip their authority to determine which species are labeled endangered in Pennsylvania.

The measure would require the Fish and Boat Commission and the Game Commission, now independent agencies, to instead run their decisions through certain legislative committees and a state regulatory review agency.

A Senate version of the bill is sponsored by Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati. His spokesman, Drew Crompton, said some industries believe the "goal posts were continuously moved" as far as what animals were on the endangered species lists, which are now controlled by the two independent state commissions.

"We're not by any means trying to one, thwart their power, two, second-guess prior decisions," Crompton said. "What this is about is, going forward, and an attempt to try to make sure that we have a publicized list of endangered species by region."

Endangered species lists are available on two state websites. The Game Commission controls what mammals and birds are listed as endangered species. Dan Brauning, Wildlife Diversity Chief, said the whole process takes about a year, from petition to approval.

"The list is not changed very often," Brauning said. "We look at a lot of data to develop these lists so, it's a slow process."

But certain industries have long wanted more exact information about the endangered animals' whereabouts. The bill in question doesn't make that information public. Instead, it allows the data to be obtained on request, and then it can be shared with others only with the permission of another state agency - the Department of Conservation and Natural Resources.

John Arway is director of the Fish and Boat Commission, with domain over fish and invertebrates on the endangered species list. He calls the bill a power grab, and is suspicious of plans to make regional data about endangered species public. Right now, such information is exempt from the state's open records law, and Right-to-Know requests focusing on the data are denied.

"Poachers would like to know [location information], because some of these species have a black market value," said Arway. "We don't want other people making decisions about species under our jurisdiction." Some developers want to know where endangered species are so they can plant their facilities elsewhere, but Arway argues developers often aren't considering the size of an animal's habitat.

Published in State House Sound Bites

Tagged under

back to top

Post a comment

Comments: 1

  • Rodger img 2013-07-22 12:18

    Since biodiversity is the foundation for the continued existence of life, including ourselves, as well as underpinning our economic well-being, before anything is changed regarding current listings, an ecological bases must be considered. Input is needed from the American Ecological Society or some equally respected group. From this article, I am not able to understand the need for the change. The thing I do know is that the loss of biodiversity continues unabated at our own peril. What the legislature needs to be looking at is this continuing loss,the reasons for this (eg., invasive species, forest fragmentation, etc.), and what can be done to protect the other creatures upon which we all depend.

Give Now

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »

Latest News from NPR

Support for WITF is provided by:

Become a WITF sponsor today »